# Subscription Model and Remote Access In Industrial Control

- Link: https://www.agilicus.com/white-papers/subscription-model-and-remote-access-in-industrial-control/
- Published: 2023-12-09T16:54:12+00:00
- Author: Don Bowman

1. [Home](https://www.agilicus.com/)
 2. Subscription Model and Remote Access In Industrial Control

![Subscription Model and Remote Access In Industrial Control](https://www.agilicus.
com/www/97c8102c-industry-4.0.svg)

Subscription Model and Remote Access In Industrial Control

---

## A Secure Journey Towards Innovation and Efficiency

Manufacturers of traditional industrial control systems are experimenting with subscription
models, license servers. These in turn require remote access.

The industry 4.0 quest for revenue creates risks for operation.

[CONTACT](https://www.agilicus.com/contact-us/)

## Executive Summary: Subscription Model and Remote Access In Industrial Control

![Licensing: Subscription Model and Remote Access In Industrial Control](https://
www.agilicus.com/www/a670f711-licensing.svg)

The industrial equipment industry is undergoing a paradigm shift towards subscription
models, driven by Industry 4.0 and the demand for flexible solutions. This shift
necessitates secure remote access for manufacturers to provide ongoing support, 
maintenance, and updates. However, securing remote access in industrial networks
presents unique challenges due to the prevalence of legacy devices, shared credentials,
and complex access requirements for multiple stakeholders. This subscription model
and remote access in industrial control shift is increasing the security risks for
all players. This white paper explores these challenges and proposes a comprehensive
strategy for secure remote access based on Zero Trust architecture and unified authentication.

## Introduction

Industrial equipment manufacturers are increasingly adopting subscription models
to offer greater flexibility and value to their customers. This subscription model
and remote access in industrial control shift is driven by several ($$$) factors,
including:

 * The rise of the Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT): IIoT enables remote data
   collection and analysis, allowing manufacturers to optimise performance, predict
   maintenance needs, and deliver value-added services.
 * Customer preference for flexibility: Subscription models provide customers with
   access to the latest equipment and services without upfront capital investment,
   enabling them to scale their operations as needed.
 * Focus on operational efficiency: Manufacturers can optimise resource allocation
   and improve service delivery through remote access capabilities.

## The Need for Secure Remote Access

Remote access is essential for supporting subscription models in several ways:

 * Providing ongoing support and maintenance: Manufacturers can remotely diagnose
   and troubleshoot issues, reducing downtime and improving equipment uptime.
 * Performing software updates and feature upgrades: Remote updates ensure that 
   equipment operates at peak performance and benefits from the latest functionalities.
 * Collecting data for performance optimisation and predictive maintenance: Remote
   data collection enables manufacturers to identify potential issues and optimise
   equipment performance before failures occur.
 * Enforcing licensing requires outbound access from the equipment.

## Challenges of Remote Access in Industrial Networks

Several challenges (due to subscription model and remote access in industrial control)
arise when implementing secure remote access in industrial networks:

 * Insecure devices: Many industrial networks contain legacy devices with limited
   security features and vulnerabilities.
 * Shared credentials and VPNs: The use of shared passwords and credentials for 
   VPN access creates a single point of failure and allows unauthorised access.
 * Multi-company access: Manufacturers, integrators, operators, and other stakeholders
   may require access to the same equipment, making it difficult to manage access
   controls.
 * Outbound internet access for licensing: Software and feature licensing may require
   outbound internet access, creating an attack surface and potential security risks.

## Real-World Examples of Security Breaches

The Colonial Pipeline attack in 2021 demonstrates the devastating consequences of
insecure remote access practices. Hackers gained access through a compromised VPN
account, disrupting fuel supply and causing widespread economic damage. Similarly,
the Florida water plant hack in 2021 highlights the dangers of shared passwords.
Hackers accessed the plant’s control system using a shared password for TeamViewer,
potentially endangering public safety.

## A Secure Approach with Zero Trust

![A diagram illustrating Zero Trust micro-segmentation with North-South restrictions,
showcasing how traffic flows are controlled and secured within an industrial network.](
https://www.agilicus.com/www/71d67d2d-zero-trust-micro-segmentation-north-south-
restrictions.drawio.svg)

Zero Trust architecture offers a robust solution for secure remote access in industrial
networks. Its core principle is “never trust, always verify,” requiring continuous
authentication and authorisation for all access requests. Zero Trust architecture
offers several benefits:

 * Least privilege access: Users are granted only the minimum level of access necessary
   to perform their tasks, limiting the impact of potential breaches.
 * Microsegmentation: The network is divided into smaller, isolated segments, preventing
   lateral movement and restricting access to critical resources. See “[Industrial Zero-Trust Micro-Segmentation](https://www.agilicus.com/white-papers/zero-trust-microsegmentation/)”
 * Unified authentication: All users are authenticated against a central corporate
   identity provider, eliminating the need for shared credentials and simplifying
   access management.
 * [Air-Gap style ](https://www.agilicus.com/white-papers/zero-trust-air-gap-lockdown-inbound-and-outbound/)
   security, open Internet style convenience.
 * Updates the “[Purdue Model](https://www.agilicus.com/white-papers/piercing-the-purdue-model-zero-trust-in-operational-technology/)”
   to modern usability.

## IEC 62443 and Open Standards for Secure Access

The IEC 62443 standard provides a framework for secure network architecture and 
communication protocols in industrial control systems. Implementing IEC 62443 recommendations
alongside Zero Trust principles further enhances security by defining zones and 
conduits, thereby minimising communication pathways and attack surfaces. Additionally,
the adoption of open standards for secure remote access protocols promotes interoperability
and simplifies integration across different vendor solutions.

## Executive Order 14028 and Government Mandates

Executive Order [14028](https://www.cisa.gov/topics/cybersecurity-best-practices/executive-order-improving-nations-cybersecurity#:~:text=The%20EO%20helps%20move%20the,within%20a%20specific%20time%20period.)
issued by the US government mandates the adoption of Zero Trust principles in federal
agencies, setting a precedent for the importance of secure remote access in critical
infrastructure sectors. This mandate emphasises the growing recognition of Zero 
Trust as a key component of cybersecurity strategy and its potential impact on security
standards in the industrial equipment industry. It can be a key part of implementing
subscription model and remote access in industrial control.

## Strategies for Multi-Company Access Management

The Agilicus AnyX platform provides isolated environments for each company, ensuring
data privacy and preventing unauthorised interaction. Each staff member of each 
company signs in with their native corporate identity, seeing AnyX as a single-sign-
on endpoint just like their corporate email. Additionally, implementing role-based
access controls and granular permission settings further enhances access management
and minimises security risks.

## Monitoring and Auditing for Continuous Security

Continuous monitoring of system activities and user logs is essential for detecting
anomalies and identifying potential security threats. Implement access and audit
logging, ideally in a SIEM architecture. If you are going to have multiple entities
each with access, due to subscription model and remote access in industrial control,
its key to have audit logging to track who has done what.

## The Future of Secure Remote Access

The future of remote access in the industrial equipment industry promises to be 
innovative and secure. Emerging technologies like AI and machine learning will further
enhance security capabilities by enabling automated threat detection and response.
Additionally, the development of open standards and secure communication protocols
will promote interoperability and simplify integration across different systems.

## Recommendations for Manufacturers and Stakeholders

 * Adopt Zero Trust Architecture: Implement Zero Trust principles to ensure continuous
   authentication and authorisation for all access requests.
 * Implement Unified Authentication: Eliminate shared credentials and simplify access
   management by using a central corporate identity provider.
 * Segment Networks: Divide the network into smaller, isolated segments to enhance
   security and limit lateral movement.
 * Deploy Secure Multi-tenancy Solutions: Manage access for multiple companies to
   the same equipment securely using dedicated platforms.
 * Monitor and Audit Activities: Continuously monitor system activities and user
   logs to detect anomalies and identify potential threats.
 * Implement Secure Communication Protocols: Use robust encryption and secure communication
   protocols for all data exchanges.
 * Stay Updated on Threats and Vulnerabilities: Regularly assess security risks 
   and patch vulnerabilities to maintain a resilient posture.
 * Collaborate and Share Best Practices: Work together with industry partners, cybersecurity
   experts, and government agencies to develop and implement best practices for 
   secure remote access.

## Conclusion

The rise of subscription model and remote access in industrial control industry 
presents unique challenges and opportunities. While remote access is crucial for
supporting this model, it also introduces cybersecurity risks. By embracing Zero
Trust architecture and implementing robust security practices, manufacturers and
stakeholders can unlock the benefits of remote access while ensuring the safety 
and integrity of their operations. This approach will pave the way for a future 
of innovation and efficiency in the industrial equipment industry, driven by secure
and reliable remote access solutions.
